The United Arab Emirates’ surprising decision to exit OPEC has left its partners in shock, presenting significant challenges for the cartel, which has managed oil prices for six decades. Officials from other member countries were taken aback on Tuesday when the UAE, OPEC’s third-largest producer, announced it would withdraw within days.
The departure threatens OPEC’s ability to influence oil prices through supply adjustments, positioning the UAE as a potential wild card in a rapidly changing global oil market. The UAE has historically opposed OPEC quotas, and its exit arrives amid unprecedented upheaval driven by factors such as the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, which has restricted production in the Gulf and rendered OPEC’s supply limits largely irrelevant. Once production resumes, the UAE is poised to increase output, heightening concerns of a potential rush for market share and price conflicts.
While officials from other OPEC+ countries expressed skepticism that the UAE’s exit would lead to a wider departure, the absence of a key member raises broader uncertainties. OPEC’s influence has diminished in recent years due to increased global production, particularly from U.S. shale oil. Saudi Arabia, attempting to maintain its role as the steward of the global market, has faced difficulties managing overproduction within its ranks. The group has already seen smaller members leave in recent years.
“OPEC’s market power will diminish,” stated Greg Brew, an analyst at Eurasia Group. He noted that the UAE’s exit would undermine the organization’s credibility, as the country represented a substantial portion of OPEC’s production capacity. Conversations with sources familiar with the situation reveal that this decision has been in the works for years, stemming from policy disagreements between Abu Dhabi and Riyadh amplified by the Covid-19 pandemic.
The tensions reflect differing approaches: the UAE aims to capitalize on its oil resources before the transition to renewable energy accelerates, while Saudi Arabia seeks to carefully manage oil supply and pricing. The competition for regional business dominance and political influence has also strained relations.
Sultan Al Jaber, CEO of the Abu Dhabi National Oil Co., is a key figure in this context, often expressing discontent with OPEC+ limits. Despite previous hints that it might exit the alliance, the UAE’s preparations for departure gained momentum at the end of last year. The ongoing conflict in Iran, which has effectively closed the Strait of Hormuz, has further constrained production and facilitated the UAE’s decision to leave, allowing it to respond to rising global fuel demand without OPEC+ restrictions.
“If oil-producing capacity is leaving the cartel’s influence, that’s bearish over a three-to-five year timeframe,” noted Clayton Seigle from the Center for Strategic and International Studies. He cautioned about the potential for a domino effect, leading to further departures from OPEC+.
OPEC’s significance stems from its history of balancing oil markets, particularly by cutting production during demand downturns, as seen during the 2008 financial crisis and the Covid pandemic in 2020. Moving forward, the responsibility for managing supply and demand will primarily fall on a dwindling number of countries within OPEC+, notably Saudi Arabia and Russia. Despite experiencing frustration over lost market share, Saudi Arabia has taken on more supply adjustments, especially as other members have increased production independently.
The UAE’s ambition to enhance its output complicates the landscape, yet the extent of its ability to do so remains uncertain. Prewar estimates suggest the UAE was already operating near capacity, with production figures varying widely; in February, the International Energy Agency reported an output of 3.64 million barrels per day, though some traders believe the actual number was higher.
“UAE production was at capacity for a long time—they ignored OPEC+ quotas,” stated Gary Ross, an oil consultant and hedge fund manager. With Saudi Arabia effectively balancing the market, the structural integrity of OPEC appears to hinge on the action of its remaining members.
For the present, OPEC does not seem on the verge of collapse, with allies indicating no immediate plans to follow the UAE’s exit. The true test of OPEC’s effectiveness will arise when it next needs to intervene in the market. As the impact of the Iran conflict persists, oil demand is projected to remain robust, creating pressure for increased supply once the Strait of Hormuz reopens.
“What’s less clear is when we will have oversupply again and the need for supply control,” commented Bob McNally, president of Rapidan Energy Group and a former White House official. “It could be many years from now.”
For more information, visit bloomberg.com.
