“If it’s so bad, why are you landing here in boatloads? Go back to your PM Modi’s shining India. We’re done with your scams and fu**ken caste culture. Go shit at the beaches of Bombay. Go MAGA on Hindus dancing and doing pollution yatras on road in US and Paris.”
This venomous rant — dripping with rage, sarcasm, and xenophobic undertones — is not an isolated comment. It’s a symptom. A symptom of a globalized resentment, a cultural backlash, and a deep, festering frustration with India’s rising nationalist image abroad — and the perceived arrogance that comes with it.
Let’s break this down. Not to defend or attack, but to understand — because beneath the profanity lies a cry that deserves to be heard, even if it’s shouted in all caps.
—
The “Boatloads” Paradox: Migration as Survival, Not Celebration
The line “If it’s so bad, why are you landing here in boatloads?” is a classic rhetorical trap — and a deeply flawed one.
People don’t migrate because their country is “shining.” They migrate because they’re seeking safety, opportunity, dignity — or fleeing persecution, economic collapse, caste violence, gender oppression, or political suffocation. Many Indians abroad — especially students, tech workers, nurses, and laborers — are not ambassadors of Modi’s India. They are survivors of its broken systems.
To tell someone escaping caste discrimination, unemployment, or communal violence to “go back” is not just cruel — it’s ignorant. Migration is not endorsement. Refugees don’t flee paradise. Economic migrants don’t leave “shining” nations — they leave nations where the shine doesn’t reach them.
And let’s be brutally honest: India may be a nuclear power with a $3.7 trillion economy, but it’s also home to 230 million undernourished people, 600 million facing acute water stress, and a justice system that takes decades to deliver verdicts. Shine? For whom?
—
“Your PM Modi’s Shining India” — A Brand vs. Reality
The phrase “shining India” is a deliberate echo of the BJP’s 2004 “India Shining” campaign — which spectacularly backfired because it ignored ground realities. Today, “Modi’s India” is marketed globally as a land of yoga, startups, temples, and missiles.
But for many Indians — especially Dalits, Muslims, Adivasis, women, and dissenters — it’s also a land of lynching videos, bulldozer justice, sedition cases, and WhatsApp-forwarded hate. “Shining India” is a curated Instagram filter — applied over a complex, often brutal, social reality.
When critics abroad say “we’re done with your scams,” they’re referencing:
- The Adani-Modi stock manipulation allegations (Hindenburg Report)
- Electoral bonds and black money laundering
- The Pegasus spyware scandal
- The Rafale, AgustaWestland, and PMCARES fund controversies
These aren’t “Western propaganda.” They’re documented investigations by global agencies, courts, and journalists — many of them Indian.
—
“Fu**ken Caste Culture” — The Elephant in Every Room
Yes. Caste is real. Caste is violent. Caste is exported.
From Silicon Valley engineers gatekeeping teams by caste surnames, to Dalit students committing suicide in premier universities, to matrimonial ads still proudly declaring “Brahmin only” — caste didn’t vanish with globalization. It boarded the plane with us.
And abroad, when upper-caste Hindus throw massive “Ram Mandir victory” parades in New Jersey or “Ganesh Chaturthi processions” that block Parisian streets — while ignoring local norms or environmental concerns — it looks less like cultural pride and more like cultural imperialism.
“Pollution yatras on road in US and Paris” — this isn’t just trolling. It’s pointing to real incidents: Ganesh idols dumped in Hudson River, firecrackers bursting at 3 AM in London suburbs, streets blocked for hours for “religious processions” in cities that require permits for protest marches.
When you demand “respect for Hindu culture” abroad but refuse to respect civic norms, you invite backlash — not bigotry.
—
“Go MAGA on Hindus…” — When Hindutva Meets Trumpism
The “Go MAGA” line is savage — but revealing.
It draws a direct parallel between the performative, chest-thumping, minority-bashing nationalism of Trump’s MAGA (Make America Great Again) and the chest-thumping, minority-bashing, “VHP meets Vistara” Hindutva on display in global diaspora events.
Think: “How’s the Josh?” chants in Times Square. “Bharat Mata Ki Jai” flash mobs in Sydney. “Modi, Our Superhero” billboards in Houston.
To many non-Indians — and even many liberal Indians — this isn’t patriotism. It’s propaganda tourism. It’s nationalism as cosplay. And when it’s accompanied by silence on lynching, love jihad laws, or bulldozing Muslim homes — it becomes toxic.
—
“Go shit at the beaches of Bombay” — The Rage Beneath the Rant
This isn’t just about India. It’s about exhaustion.
Exhaustion with performative piety. Exhaustion with victimhood Olympics (“We’re persecuted Hindus!” — while running the most powerful government in Indian history). Exhaustion with spiritual bypassing (“Why are you angry? Just chant Hare Krishna!”). Exhaustion with the hypocrisy of preaching “Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam” (the world is one family) while treating your own Dalit neighbor like untouchable.
The beaches of Bombay — now Mumbai — are already drowning in sewage, plastic, and unchecked development. Telling someone to “go shit there” is grotesque — but it’s also symbolic. It’s saying: Your problems are your own. Don’t export your chaos. Don’t colonize our peace with your noise.
When you carry your nationalism like a flamethrower into someone else’s backyard, don’t be surprised when they ask you to leave — or curse you out.
What’s the Answer?
Not more hate. Not more defensiveness.
The answer is humility.
If you’re proud of India — fine. Celebrate it quietly. Respect local laws. Clean up after your events. Listen to criticism. Acknowledge caste. Stop pretending everything is perfect.
If you’re part of the diaspora — don’t be a cultural bulldozer. Be a bridge.
And to those hurling the rage — your anger is valid, but your language dehumanizes. And dehumanization, no matter who does it, is the first step toward violence.
—
Final Thought
India is not a monolith. Modi does not represent every Indian. Hindutva is not Hinduism. And not every Indian abroad is a flag-waving fanatic.
But the perception is growing — and perceptions, once cemented, become reality.
If India wants global respect, it must earn it — not demand it. And that starts with introspection, accountability, and yes — cleaning up its own beaches, both literal and metaphorical.
Until then, expect more rage. More rants. More “go back to your shining India.”
Because when you export arrogance, you import anger.
